← All articles

15 November 2026

Your Restraint of Trade Is Probably Valid. Whether It Stops You Depends on What You Hand Your Employer

SA courts presume restraints of trade are valid, but employers often lose on evidence. What the case law says, where hidden restraints sit, and what to do.

Picture a key account manager at a Johannesburg packaging company. Eleven years in, she has decided to leave and start a distribution business serving the same kind of customers she has looked after for a decade. Somewhere in a drawer is a contract she signed in 2015. It contains a 24-month restraint of trade covering the whole of South Africa.

She has heard the same two things everyone hears. "They never enforce those." And "restraints aren't really enforceable in South Africa anyway." The first is sometimes true. The second is wrong, and believing it is how people end up on the wrong side of an urgent interdict three weeks after launching their business.

South African law starts from the position that your restraint is valid. The burden of proving otherwise sits with you. That sounds like bad news, and in one sense it is. But the case law of the last two years shows something more useful for anyone planning an exit: employers lose these cases far more often on evidence than on law. Most of the employers who win were handed their evidence by the employee, usually in the final weeks of employment. So the more useful question to ask is what your employer could actually prove you are taking with you.

The cases that matter

  • Restraints are valid and enforceable unless the employee proves they are unreasonable (Magna Alloys and Research v Ellis, Appellate Division, 1984).
  • Courts test reasonableness through four questions set out in Basson v Chilwan (Appellate Division, 1993).
  • The Labour Appeal Court cut a nationwide two-year restraint to one year in Sadan v Workforce Staffing (2023), rather than setting it aside.
  • Dismissal does not cancel a restraint, the Labour Appeal Court confirmed in Backsports v Motlhanke (27 October 2025).
  • A restraint the employee never signed was refused in Generator and Plant Hire SA v Hall (Northern Cape High Court, 17 July 2026).
  • In Adviceworx v Roux, 820 clients followed departing employees to a competitor within weeks, and the court granted final enforcement (reported by Webber Wentzel, July 2026).

The law starts on your employer's side

Since Magna Alloys and Research v Ellis in 1984, South African courts have treated a restraint of trade as valid and binding unless the person resisting it proves that enforcing it would be unreasonable and contrary to public policy. Before 1984, South Africa followed the English approach, where the employer has to justify the restraint. The Appellate Division reversed that, and the position has held for four decades.

This matters more than most people realise. In the United Kingdom, a non-compete is unenforceable unless the employer can show it protects a legitimate interest and goes no further than necessary. The UK government went further in November 2025 and published a working paper on capping non-competes at three months or banning them below a salary threshold, with consultation closing on 18 February 2026. South Africa has no equivalent reform on the table. There is no statutory cap on how long a restraint can run, and no requirement that you be paid separately for agreeing to one. Webber Wentzel's July 2026 guidance confirms that your ordinary remuneration counts as sufficient consideration.

Reasonableness is tested through the four questions from Basson v Chilwan (1993):

  • Does the employer have an interest that deserves protection after employment ends?
  • Is that interest threatened by what the employee is doing?
  • Does that interest outweigh the employee's interest in being economically active?
  • Is there some other public policy reason to enforce or reject the restraint?
  • The first question is where most of the real fighting happens, and the courts recognise two kinds of protectable interest: confidential information (pricing, margins, customer lists, strategy, formulas) and trade connections (relationships with customers and suppliers that you built on the employer's time and with the employer's resources). The Supreme Court of Appeal made the corollary clear in Automotive Tooling Systems v Wilkens (2006): a restraint that exists only to stop competition, with no protectable interest behind it, is unenforceable.

    One more principle cuts against employees. In Reddy v Siemens Telecommunications (Supreme Court of Appeal, 2007), the court enforced a 12-month restraint without proof that the employee had actually misused anything. The risk that confidential information could be disclosed was enough. So "I haven't used anything" is a weaker defence than it sounds, if you are going to work somewhere that information would be useful.

    Courts trim restraints far more often than they throw them out

    The Labour Appeal Court in Sadan v Workforce Staffing (2023) accepted that a staffing company's interests deserved protection across the whole country, then held that a two-year restraint was excessive and cut it to one year. The Labour Court did the same in Vanhattan Lifting v Herselman (7 July 2026): legitimate interests established, two years too long, period reduced.

    This is the outcome people tend to misjudge. If your restraint is too long or too wide, the likely result of fighting it is a shorter restraint that still binds you. A court will not necessarily strike the whole clause. For someone planning a business, the difference between 24 months and 12 is significant, but it is still a year of not trading in your obvious market.

    There are limits to how far courts will rescue a badly drafted clause. Webber Wentzel notes that a court can read down an overbroad restraint only where the offending part is clearly separable. And reasonableness is judged at the time the employer tries to enforce, which cuts both ways. A restraint that looked proportionate when you were a junior analyst may look excessive against a different role a decade later. Equally, one that looked harmless when you signed it may bite hard once you are running the region's biggest accounts.

    Where employers actually lose: the evidence

    Employers lose restraint cases most often because they cannot prove the protectable interest in concrete terms. Three judgments from 2025 and 2026 show the pattern.

    In Fidelity Services Group v Goveia (Western Cape High Court, reported April 2026), a regional sales manager had signed a three-year national restraint. After leaving in September 2025 he became a member of Mach 1 Security, a small firm operating in Fish Hoek and Simonstown for about 20 years. Fidelity's urgent application failed. The court found that his knowledge of the industry was general skill and experience, which no restraint can take away, and that Fidelity had shown no concrete harm.

    In Cut-N-Weld Supplies v Britz and Merchant West Specialised Finance v Le Grange, both discussed in Webber Wentzel's July 2026 review, the employers lost because they asserted that information was confidential without specifying what it was, why it was confidential, or how the employee had access to it.

    In FX Group v Steyn, the employee joined a direct competitor, but in a product division where the former employer had no involvement at all. Enforcement was refused. Joining a competitor is not automatically a breach. The question is whether your new role genuinely threatens the interest the restraint protects.

    Drafting also fails employers. In Didi Waterproofing Services v Els (Labour Court, Cape Town, 20 April 2026), a site manager left and set up his own company. His restraint barred him from "establishing a new business" but did not say "competing". The court refused to read the word in, held that a blanket ban on starting any business protected no legitimate interest, and dismissed the application with costs. It also found that the employee's earlier written agreement that the restraint was "fair, reasonable and necessary" did not save it.

    Now look at the cases employers win.

    In Atlas 360 Commercial Vehicle Services v De Witt (Labour Court, 2026), a sales executive emailed herself customer lists and confidential business information before resigning to join a competitor. The restraint was enforced. In HR & Skills Market v Strydom (Labour Court, 11 September 2025), an HR consultant ran a competing business while still employed, servicing clients with her employer's pricing and client information. The court found a breach of both the restraint and her common-law duty of loyalty. In TWK Agri v Holtzhausen (Labour Court, 23 June 2025), more than twenty clients cancelled their policies within weeks of a broker leaving, several following her to her new firm. And in Adviceworx v Roux, 820 clients moved and a further 433 partially terminated their mandates, alongside evidence of copied and deleted data.

    The pattern is hard to miss. Where employers win, the employee has usually created the evidence: the forwarded spreadsheet, the side business run from the company laptop, the client exodus in the first month. Where employers lose, they are usually trying to restrain general competence with a vaguely worded clause and no specifics.

    So for anyone planning to leave and start something, the biggest risk is your own conduct in the last three months of employment. The wording of the restraint matters less than that.

    The restraints people don't know they have

    Most professionals assume they would remember signing a restraint. In practice, restraints sit in documents people skim, sign under time pressure, or inherit without signing anything new. The courts have generally held people to them.

    Where it hidesWhat the courts have said
    Your day-one employment contractSigning binds you. In a 2017 matter reported by Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr, the court rejected an employee's argument about the circumstances of signing and held that if she needed more time to read the contract, she should have asked.
    Your offer letterIn TMA Express Road v Scholtz (Johannesburg High Court, June 2025), the offer letter itself stated that acceptance was subject to a 24-month restraint covering South Africa.
    A sale or restructuring of your employerIn Slo-Jo Innovation v Beedle (Labour Court, 2022), a restraint signed with one company in 2007 transferred to a new subsidiary in a 2018 restructure under section 197 of the Labour Relations Act. The new employer could enforce it.
    A share sale or shareholder agreementIn Citadel Holdings v Stratfold (Western Cape High Court, 30 June 2026), undertakings signed when the respondent sold her shareholding were enforced across South Africa until May 2028. Courts treat restraints given in commercial deals more strictly than employment restraints.
    A revised contract signed mid-employmentIn Allens Meshco v Krige (Western Cape High Court, 12 March 2026), a restraint signed voluntarily as part of improved employment conditions was enforced after the employee resigned shortly before a disciplinary hearing.
    Being dismissedIn Backsports v Motlhanke (Labour Appeal Court, 27 October 2025), the restraint survived dismissal for misconduct. The only recognised exception is a dismissal engineered fraudulently or in bad faith to trigger the restraint.

    Shareholder and share-sale restraints deserve particular attention from corporate professionals. If you hold equity through a management buy-in, a long-term incentive scheme or a founder stake in a business you later sold, the restraint may sit in the share documents. The employment contract may say nothing. People check the contract, find nothing, and assume they are clear.

    There is some protection the other way too. In Generator and Plant Hire SA v Hall (Northern Cape High Court, 17 July 2026), the appointment letter said the employee "will be required to sign a restraint of trade". He never did, in almost ten years. After he resigned in September 2025, the employer set out 24-month terms covering the Northern Cape for the first time. The court held that a promise to sign later is an agreement to agree, refused to imply or infer a restraint from silence, and dismissed the application with costs. An employer cannot add a restraint after you resign without your agreement.

    Settlement agreements can also work in your favour. In Wheelwright v CP De Leeuw Johannesburg, the Labour Appeal Court held that "full and final settlement" wording covering all claims extinguished the employer's right to enforce the restraint. If you are negotiating an exit through the CCMA or a retrenchment package, the wording of that settlement may matter more than the original clause.

    If you have one: what to do before you resign

    The time to deal with a restraint is before you hand in your notice. Once you have resigned, your leverage drops and the clock starts.

  • Find every document. Employment contract, offer letter, any amended contracts, incentive scheme rules, shareholder or share sale agreements, and the policies your contract incorporates by reference. If you can't find your contract, ask HR for a copy before you signal any intention to leave.
  • Map the clause precisely. Write down the duration, the geography, and exactly what is restricted. Competing, soliciting customers, poaching staff and dealing with suppliers are separate restrictions, and many clauses contain only some of them. Didi Waterproofing turned on a single missing word.
  • Run the Basson test honestly against yourself. What confidential information did you genuinely have? Which customer relationships were built on the employer's platform? If the answer is "a lot", assume a court will find a protectable interest and plan accordingly.
  • Design the business around the protectable interest. A different customer segment, a different product line, a different region or a different role in the value chain can take you outside the restraint's purpose. FX Group v Steyn turned on exactly this. Write down why your new business does not threaten the specific interests you identified, because that reasoning will become your affidavit if it comes to that.
  • Keep a clean exit. Do not forward documents, client lists or pricing to personal accounts. Do not contact clients about your plans while employed. Do not register the company and start trading while you are still on the payroll. Every employer win discussed above rests on conduct like this.
  • Ask for a written release. Many employers will narrow or waive a restraint for someone who is going into a non-threatening space, especially if you ask early and explain the business. A release is only worth something in writing, signed by someone with authority.
  • Use the exit negotiation. If you are leaving through a retrenchment or a settled dispute, ask for the restraint to be waived or narrowed as part of the package, and read the settlement wording carefully.
  • Get advice before you act, from someone who litigates these matters. An hour with an employment lawyer reviewing your documents and your business plan is cheap compared to defending an urgent application.
  • If your employer paid you a specific amount for the restraint, two things follow. Courts find it harder to accept hardship arguments from an employee who was paid to accept the restriction, although payment alone does not guarantee enforcement. And the payment is taxable as income in your hands: in Walter v CSARS (Johannesburg High Court, November 2023), a restraint payment to an individual was confirmed as gross income under the Income Tax Act.

    If the letter of demand arrives

    Restraint disputes move fast. The usual sequence is a letter of demand asking for written undertakings, followed by an urgent application to the Labour Court or High Court if the undertakings are not given. Respond quickly, through an attorney, and do not sign undertakings you are not able to keep.

    Urgency is often where the employer's case is weakest. Courts treat restraints as inherently urgent, but they will not hear a matter on the urgent roll where the employer created the urgency through its own delay. The Labour Court in Cape Town struck an application off the roll in 2025 ([2025] ZALCCT 1) because the employer took a leisurely approach while exploring settlement. The Western Cape High Court did the same in 2025 ([2025] ZAWCHC 34) where the employer took 48 days to come to court. Didi Waterproofing also found that the employer's delays undermined urgency.

    Keep a dated record of every communication from the moment your employer becomes aware of your plans. If they wait, that timeline matters.

    In the Labour Court, Rule 39 allows the employee a fourth affidavit in restraint applications, which gives you a chance to respond to new material in the employer's reply. Use it carefully. Your affidavit should deal specifically with what confidential information you had, why it is stale or general, and why your new business does not threaten the employer's customers. Vague denials tend to lose and specific answers tend to win, for the same reason they do when the employer is the one making the case.

    Costs follow the result. In both Hall and Didi Waterproofing, the unsuccessful employer was ordered to pay costs. The same applies in reverse if you lose.

    What this means practically

    The reassurance that restraints are unenforceable comes from the minority of cases where employers overreached and couldn't prove their interest. The law itself favours the employer, and the likeliest result of a fight over an excessive restraint is a shorter one that still binds you.

    Your position is strongest when you have read every document you signed, built a business that sits outside the interest your employer can genuinely protect, left without a single forwarded file, and asked for a release in writing before you resigned. Most people who get caught do so through their own conduct in the final months of employment. If you are already planning that exit, the planning period is when you have the most room to act.

    Frequently asked questions

    Are restraints of trade enforceable in South Africa?

    Yes. Since Magna Alloys and Research v Ellis (Appellate Division, 1984), South African courts treat restraints of trade as valid and enforceable unless the employee proves they are unreasonable and contrary to public policy. Courts frequently reduce excessive restraints rather than cancel them, as the Labour Appeal Court did in Sadan v Workforce Staffing (2023), cutting two years to one.

    Can my employer enforce a restraint of trade I never signed?

    Rarely. In Generator and Plant Hire SA v Hall (Northern Cape High Court, 17 July 2026), the court refused to enforce a restraint the employee never signed in almost ten years of employment, even though his appointment letter said he would be required to sign one. An employer also cannot add a restraint after you resign without your agreement.

    Does a restraint of trade still apply if I am dismissed or retrenched?

    Generally yes. In Backsports v Motlhanke (27 October 2025), the Labour Appeal Court confirmed that the reason employment ends does not affect whether a restraint is enforceable. The only recognised exception is a dismissal engineered fraudulently or in bad faith. A settlement agreement with broad "full and final" wording may, however, extinguish the restraint, as held in Wheelwright v CP De Leeuw.

    What makes a restraint of trade unenforceable in South Africa?

    A restraint fails when the employer cannot prove a protectable interest, meaning specific confidential information or customer connections. In Fidelity Services Group v Goveia (Western Cape High Court, 2026), the court held that general industry knowledge and skills are not protectable. A restraint that only blocks competition, with no such interest behind it, is unenforceable under Automotive Tooling Systems v Wilkens (SCA, 2006).

    ← All articles