Buy or build: what you are actually choosing
Starting a business from nothing means building demand, systems, staff and a name from a standing start, with a high chance of failing before any of it exists. Buying one means paying for all of that upfront, already working, and inheriting whatever is wrong with it that the seller would rather you did not find. Neither is safer. They fail in different ways.
| Buying an existing business | Building from scratch | |
|---|---|---|
| Day one | Revenue, staff and customers already there | Nothing until you create it |
| Main risk | Inheriting problems the seller hid | Never reaching a viable business at all |
| Upfront cost | A purchase price, often substantial | Lower to start, funded by your time |
| What you control | A going concern with its own habits | Every decision, from a blank page |
| Where it goes wrong | Overpaying, or the value walking out with the owner | Running out of money or time before it works |
The honest summary is that buying suits people who can fund a purchase and would rather manage an existing operation than invent one, and building suits people with more time than capital and a specific idea they believe in. If you are not yet sure which describes you, or you do not have a defined business in mind, that is a question for Stage 1, not this page. This cluster assumes you have decided to buy and are looking for the right target.
Where to look
There is no single marketplace for businesses the way there is for property or cars. Deals surface through several channels, each with its own character and its own catch.
The broker model, honestly
This is the part almost nobody writes down, because almost everyone writing about buying a business in South Africa is, or is paid by, a broker.
A business broker is paid by the seller. Their commission is a percentage of the sale price, payable when the deal closes. Read that twice, because everything else follows from it. The broker's incentive is a high price and a closed deal. It is not the right deal for you, and it is not you walking away, however helpful and professional the individual broker is.
The mandate. When a broker lists a business, they hold a mandate from the seller, sole or open, that sets their commission and their exclusivity. It is a contract between the broker and the seller. You are not a party to it and you owe the broker nothing. You are free to have your own advisers, to negotiate directly, and to walk at any point.
Why asking prices are inflated. Asking prices carry commission, room to negotiate down, and the seller's own optimism about what they built. The number on the listing is a starting position dressed as a value. What the business is actually worth, and how you work that out for yourself rather than accepting the broker's figure, is the whole of the next page.
What a good broker actually adds.A good broker is still worth having in the deal. They bring you businesses you would never have found, keep a slow process moving, and manage the seller's expectations in a way a buyer cannot. Use them for access and momentum. Do not use them for advice on whether to buy or what to pay. Those are yours, and your own accountant's.
Is this business a fit, honestly
Assume you have found a specific business that interests you. Before the numbers, before an offer, sit with four honest questions. This is about surfacing the issues, not resolving them yet.
If these questions raise a deeper uncertainty, not about this business but about whether you know what you want at all, that is worth resolving before you spend money. Stage 1 is built for exactly that.
The first conversation with a seller
The first real conversation with a seller is not a negotiation. It is you gathering information and reading how freely it is given. What a seller volunteers, and what they go quiet on, tells you as much as the answers themselves.
- Why are you selling, and why now?
- How involved are you in the business day to day, and what happens when you are not there?
- What would you fix if you were staying another five years?
- Who are the key staff and customers, and how would they react to a new owner?
- Has the business been for sale before, and what happened?
Listen for the questions that produce a pause, a redirection, or an answer that is a little too smooth. A seller with nothing to hide answers all of these easily. Where an answer is evasive, you have found the first thing to verify. Verifying it, and working out what the business is actually worth, is where this journey goes next: evaluating the financials.
